Guest post: The National Minimum Wage traps that catch out well-meaning employers
A guest blog from our payroll partner Ascend Payroll. By Paul Chappell, Head of Legislation and Compliance.
Ask most business owners whether they pay the National Minimum Wage (NMW), and you'll get a quick yes. The hourly rate is above the legal minimum, so job done.
The catch is that NMW compliance is measured on what someone actually receives for every hour they actually work. Unpaid minutes, extra hours, deductions and workplace benefits can all chip away at that figure, and plenty of employers end up underpaying without ever meaning to.
The stakes are going up too. The Fair Work Agency took legal responsibility for minimum wage enforcement in April 2026, and its first naming round in September listed nearly 660 employers.
Here are the traps we see most often, and how to stay clear of them.
Salaried staff count too
NMW applies to salaried employees in exactly the same way as hourly workers. To check it, you divide their pay by the hours they actually worked in the pay period, including the hours nobody wrote down.
Those unrecorded "shadow hours" are where a decent salary quietly comes undone. Take a manager on £30,000 contracted to 37.5 hours a week. In a normal month, that's £2,500 for 162.5 hours, or about £15.38 an hour.
Now add a busy month. Stocktake, year-end, or the run-up to Christmas adds 10 hours a week, around 43 extra hours across the month. That's roughly 206 hours for the same £2,500, or about £12.15 an hour, which is below today's £12.71 National Living Wage (and way below the new rate of £13.21 from April 2027).
The same goes for staff who answer emails on the sofa, take calls on their day off or log in on Sunday night to get ahead. If it's work, it counts, wherever and whenever it happens. The courts settled this years ago in British Nursing Association v Inland Revenue (2002), where staff answering a booking line from home overnight were found to be working for the whole shift, quiet spells included.
We've written more on this in the hidden problem of salaried workers and unpaid hours.
Every pay period stands on its own
NMW is checked one pay reference period at a time. That's the period you pay for, whether it's a week, a fortnight or a month, and it can never be longer than a month.
So a quiet August can't balance out a frantic December. If extra unpaid hours drag someone below the minimum in a single pay period, you've underpaid them, even if their pay across the year looks perfectly healthy.
This is where seasonal businesses get caught. Retail at Christmas, hospitality in the summer, accountancy practices in January: the peaks are exactly when hours climb, and nobody's counting.
Ten minutes here, ten minutes there
Unpaid time at either end of a shift is one of the most common reasons employers get named. It rarely looks like much on the day, but it adds up across a workforce and goes back years.
- Briefings and security checks. Argos had to repay staff after briefings before clocking on and bag searches after shifts were left out of paid time. At Sports Direct's Shirebrook warehouse, an employment tribunal in Nexus Workforce v HMRC accepted that workers had spent unpaid time in security queues.
- Clocking rules that round in your favour. Sports Direct workers were reportedly docked 15 minutes for clocking in a minute late, with nothing extra for staying late. Any system that rounds start times up or finish times down can push pay under the line.
- Travel for work. The commute from home to a normal workplace doesn't count, but travel between jobs does. In a tribunal case brought by 10 homecare workers in Haringey, travel and waiting time of up to 60 minutes between appointments was treated as working time, and the employers paid out over £100,000.
- Setting up and closing down. Opening tills, firing up equipment, cleaning down, cashing up, setting the alarm and locking up are all work if you require them. So is changing into protective clothing on site. If staff clock out and then do these jobs, that time still counts.
Care employers face their own set of rules around overnight work, which we cover in NMW and sleep-in shifts.
Uniforms, kit and other costs
If staff have to pay for something they need for the job, that cost comes off their pay when you check NMW. It makes no difference whether you deduct it through payroll or they buy it themselves.
Uniforms are the classic example. Retailer Monsoon was named after requiring staff to buy its clothing to wear as uniform. For anyone paid at or near the minimum, a £20 polo shirt or a pair of safety boots is enough to tip them under in that pay period. And it doesn't have to be branded workwear. If the dress code specifies a colour and the employee has to buy something suitable, that is classed as uniform.
The same applies to tools, equipment and unreimbursed work expenses. Accommodation is different again. If you provide it, only a set daily amount (the accommodation offset, £11.10 a day now) can count towards NMW pay.
The simplest fix is to provide uniforms and kit free of charge. If that isn't practical, build enough headroom into pay rates to absorb the cost.
Salary sacrifice has one rule you can't sign away

Salary sacrifice schemes such as cycle to work, electric cars, and extra pension contributions are popular, and for good reason. But for NMW purposes, it's the pay left after the sacrifice that counts. Even if the employee is keen to join, the arrangement can't take them below the minimum.
Take Hanna. She's 23, works 40 hours a week and earns £12.75 an hour (£510 a week). She'd like to join your cycle-to-work scheme with a £20 weekly sacrifice. That takes her effective rate down to £12.25 an hour, below today's £12.71, so as her employer you can't let her take part on those terms.
Now take Sarah. She's 25, works the same hours on £13.25 an hour (£530 a week) and makes the same £20 sacrifice. Her effective rate drops to £12.75, which clears today's minimum by 4p.
From April 2027, the National Living Wage rises to £13.21. Unless Sarah's pay goes up, the arrangement that's compliant today leaves her 46p an hour short. Her scheme is exactly the same, but the goalposts have moved.
That's why sacrifice arrangements need reviewing every time the rates change, with a safety margin built in, ideally before the new rates kick in.
The new rates from April 2027
In the Budget on 28 October 2026, the government accepted the Low Pay Commission's recommendations in full. Every rate rises by 3.9% on 1 April 2027 (IER, Policy Pros).
| Rate | Now (from April 2026) | From 1 April 2027 |
| National Living Wage (21 and over) | £12.71 | £13.21 |
| 18 to 20 | £10.85 | £11.27 |
| 16 to 17 | £8.00 | £8.31 |
| Apprentice | £8.00 | £8.31 |
| Accommodation offset (per day) | £11.10 | £11.53 |
A 50p rise sounds modest, but it shrinks the gap that keeps salaried staff and sacrifice schemes compliant. Our £30,000 manager from earlier can work only about 6 extra hours a week in a month before falling below £13.21. The government has also committed to bringing the 18 to 20 rate into line with the National Living Wage, so expect bigger jumps for younger workers in future years.
Enforcement is tightening at the same time. From April 2027, around 500 HMRC minimum wage staff are due to move into the Fair Work Agency, which can recover arrears going back six years. Penalties can reach 200% of the underpayment, and employers can be publicly named.
The businesses that cope best treat each rate change as a planning date. Budget for the new rates now, then review pay bands, salaried roles that sit close to the threshold, benefits and sacrifice schemes well before April.
A quick NMW health check
- Record the hours salaried staff actually work, especially in peak periods.
- Pay for every minute you require people to be at work, including briefings, searches, setting up and closing down.
- Check your clocking system doesn't round in your favour.
- Pay for travel between jobs and sites.
- Provide uniforms and kit free, or factor the cost into pay.
- Test every salary sacrifice arrangement against the April 2027 rates now.
- Check compliance pay period by pay period, never as an annual average.
Accountants advising SME clients can run the same checks at year-end and before each April rate change.
Need a hand?
Ascend Payroll is a managed payroll bureau that checks NMW compliance every pay period, so problems get spotted before they become arrears. If you'd like a second pair of eyes on your pay structures, salaried roles or benefit schemes ahead of April, get in touch with the team.
Paul Chappell is Head of Legislation and Compliance at Ascend Payroll. He spent 14 years at the Inland Revenue (now HMRC) as a Tax Inspector, Employer Compliance Manager and PAYE Auditor, and now keeps Ascend's team and clients ahead of every legislative change.
Let’s build a stronger future, together
At Amica HR, we’re proud to support all our clients with a network of trusted HR partnerships, all dedicated to helping you create a thriving, engaged, and productive workplace.
When you choose to work with us, you gain more than outsourced HR support, you gain a team that’s invested in your success and growth.If you’d like to explore how our partnerships can benefit your business, or if you’re interested in becoming an Amica HR partner, get in touch today.


